Does Christopher Nolan use a recurring theme of flawed male characters to classify himself as an auteur?
Projector: Image of Christopher Nolan (Item 19)
Speaker: Christopher Nolan is an English-American Filmmaker, in such a short time of film making since the late 90s he has gone from making low-budget independent films like 'Following' (1998) to big blockbuster films such as 'Inception' (2010) and even his own 'Batman' trilogy (2005-2012). He is now one of highest-grossing directors in the history of film, thus leading him to be thought as one of the most successful filmmakers of the 21st century.
People that watch Christopher Nolan's films will notice a recurring theme of flawed male characters which can often be caused by memory problems such as Leonard Shelby 'Memento' and characters in a negative psychological state such as Cobb from 'Inception' and also the recurring them of 'personal identity' which is shown by Batman in 'Batman Begins' with Batman being his alter ego to Bruce Wayne. This shows Christopher Nolan as an auteur and supports my point because the 'auteur policy' states that "An auteur is a director who manifests a consistency of style and theme across his or her films."(7) It also states that "The director is privileged by auteur critics because he or she is one who visualises the script on screen." (7) This being shown in the following films that I will discuss.
Projector: Play scene of 'Cobb' confessing guilt to Mal from 'Inception' (1)
Speaker: In this scene it already shows the fact of 'Christopher Nolan' using a theme of flawed male characters because the character 'Cobb' already expresses his guilt towards his wife saying that he created an inception in her mind. This already identifies 'Christopher Nolan' as an auteur because "an auteur in the Hollywood studio system is a director who transcends the script by imposing on it his or her own style and vision." (7) This is shown within the scene because it shows the theme of the male character being flawed of 'Cobb' by his negativity of emotion by the use of guilt.
Projector: Play the final scene of 'Inception' (Limbo scene) (1)
Speaker: Again within this scene it shows the character 'Cobb' as a flawed character because the suggests his feel of him being trapped in a dream. It also suggests the character is flawed because he really can't tell the difference between what is the real world and what is just an 'Inception' in his mind by the use of the totem of a spinning top to tell what is an inevitability of whether what he is seeing is real by the spinning top still spinning towards the end which suggests he has a choice whether to believe what is real and what isn't this leading the character of 'Cobb' of being a flawed male character which supports my point of defining 'Christopher Nolan' as an 'auteur'.
Projector: Play 'Batman Begins' (opening scene set in graveyard) (2)
Speaker: Like that in comparison to the film of 'Inception' the character 'Bruce Wayne' in 'Batman Begins' of this particular scene again shows the male character as being flawed. The reason for this being is because it shows not just his parents tombstone but also the characters 'fear' of Bats as he falls into the pit of the grave. This again supports my point of 'Christopher Nolan' using male flawed characters to identify himself as an 'auteur'.
Projector: Play 'Batman Begins' (Bruce training with League of Shadows) (2)
Speaker: Within this scene it refers back to the opening scene which shows Christopher Nolan's male characters being flawed, because as Bruce Wayne (Batman's alter ego) is training with the League of Shadows, Henri asks Bruce what he fears. Then within this scene we see "Almost instantly, we see a shot of hundreds of bats rapidly flying past Bruce as he lies in the hole. But in a subsequent shot from the hole, looking upward to the light, the film depicts Bruce's father climbing down with a rope in order to rescue him." (5) From this research it shows again the use of a flawed male character to represent Christopher Nolan as an 'auteur' because it clearly states the character of Bruce needed to be rescued and comforted by his father Thomas, who despite rescuing him is actually dead, this could represent Bruce's desperate need of his father and not wanting to be a failure in his fathers eyes, which represents Bruce as a flawed male character.
Projector: Play scene from 'Memento' where 'Leonard Shelby' is with 'Teddy' (3)
Speaker: This scene from 'Memento' again shows one of 'Christopher Nolan's' male characters as being flawed because the character 'Leonard' does not know who he is because he cannot remember because he has amnesia, because of the fact that he even has amnesia makes him a flawed character because he does not remember anything about himself friends or family and the only thing he actually trusts is the pictures he has of people and what he needs to do, in this case the picture of 'Teddy' underneath lists "Kill him" already making the character of 'Leonard Shelby' flawed because he doesn't know anything about anyone so his whole entrustment is within photos with writing underneath which again supports my point of 'Christopher Nolan' identifying himself as an 'auteur' by the use of flawed male characters.
Projector: Scene from 'Inception' where Cobb is on the Train track telling his wife he created an inception in her head. (1)
Speaker: Within this scene it clearly shows again the use of Christopher Nolan representing male characters as flawed because referring back to the first clip shown of Inception of where the character 'Cobb' confessed his guilt of creating an inception in her mind, the scene before this shows the explaining of how it happened where 'Cobb and his wife 'Mal' are lying on the train track waiting for the train to hit them so that they wake up, however this is what ultimately lead to the Inception within 'Mal's' mind leading to a simulacra where Mal cannot tell the difference between the real world and fake world even by the use of her spinning top 'totem' which usually tells her when she is in a dream world and she now does not believe in what the 'totem' tells her because the character 'Cobb' her husband lead her to believe this, which ultimately leads to him being another flawed male character to show Christopher Nolan's directorial work as an auteur.
Bibliography Reference Items:
(1) Inception (Film): 2010 Directed by: Christopher Nolan
(2) Batman Begins (Film): 2005 Directed by: Christopher Nolan
(3) Memento (Film): 2000 Directed by: Christopher Nolan
(4)
The Cinema of Christopher Nolan: Imagining the impossible (2015) Author(s) by: Jacqueline Furby and Stuart Joy
(5) The Fictional Christopher Nolan (2012) Author: Todd McGowan
(6) Memento (2009) Author: Andrew Kania
(7) 'Teach Yourself Film Studies' (2003) Author: Warren Buckland
(8)
http://movierdo.com/the-flawed-heroes-of-christopher-nolans-films-the-evil-in-the-good/
(9)
https://narrativeinart.wordpress.com/nolan/
(10)
https://filmandphilosophy.com/2011/09/15/memento-mind-memory-and-personal-identity/
(11)
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/film/filmmakersonfilm/7894376/Christopher-Nolan-interview-for-Inception.html
(12)
http://www.mtv.com/news/2764224/interview-christopher-nolan-talks-inception/
(13)
http://www.bbc.co.uk/films/2000/10/16/christopher_nolan_ii_interview.shtml
(19) http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0634240/
Reject Items:
(14) The Dark Knight Rises (Film) (2012) Director: Christopher Nolan
(15) The Dark Knight Trilogy Books (2012) By: Christopher Nolan
(16)
http://www.timeout.com/london/film/why-christopher-nolan-is-not-the-new-stanley-kubrick-1
(17)
http://www.nolanfans.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=21&t=3419
(18)
http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/race/christopher-nolan-interstellar-critics-making-760897